The Ask and the Answer

The Ask and the Answer by Patrick NessThe Ask and the Answer by Patrick Ness
Chaos Walking # 2
Publisher: Walker Books
Number of pages: 517
My copy: US paperback, bought from Fully Booked

Fleeing before a relentless army, Todd has carried a desperately wounded Viola right into the hands of their worst enemy, Mayor Prentiss.

Immediately separated from Viola and imprisoned, Todd is forced to learn the ways of the Mayor’s new order.

But what secrets are hiding just outside of town? And where is Viola? Is she even alive? And who are the mysterious Answer?

And then, one day, the bombs begin to explode…

* * *

So it’s been a little over a year since I read The Knife of Never Letting Go, the first book in the Chaos Walking series. Having loved that book, it would have made sense if I immediately dived into the second one, especially since I had a copy. But here’s the thing I realized with the Patrick Ness books I’ve read so far: they’re all pretty emotional, the kind that makes you need some time and space in between his books to prepare yourself for another ride. Especially if you’re one who gets a bit attached to the characters, like me.

Spoilers for the first book inevitable at this point forward. And so now that a year has passed, I pick up The Ask and the Answer. The book picks up almost immediately where Knife left off: Todd wakes up and finds himself tied to a chair facing Mayor Prentiss, now President Prentiss, questioning him. Todd had only one concern in mind — where Viola was, and if she’s still alive, especially since he remembered carrying her almost-lifeless body towards what they thought was Haven. The “haven” that they expected is now New Prentisstown, with the Mayor as the new leader. But it seemed like the Mayor doesn’t want Todd dead. He spares his life, teams him up with his son Davy to do some work in New Prentisstown, promising Todd that Viola will live if he follows the rules. The Mayor suddenly doesn’t seem to be the person Todd believed he was…but can he be trusted?

In the other side of town, Viola wakes up, far from dead. She meets Mistress Coyle, one the best healers in Haven, and Viola finds out that the Mayor has locked all women in for reasons yet unknown. As Viola recovers, she becomes an apprentice healer, constantly worried about Todd and if he has survived whatever the Mayor had in store for them. But soon, Viola finds out that there’s more to Mistress Coyle than being a normal and best healer in New Prentisstown — and she needs Viola on her side.

Then the bombs start exploding.

The Ask and the Answer picks up the pace from the first book, dropping us straight into the conflict. Todd and Viola’s separation tears at them both, and while they don’t really know what to do or who to trust, they know they have to be with each other, no matter what. They both grow up lots in this installment, with all the politics and manipulation and desperation going on around them. This is also far darker than its predecessor, tackling themes such as torture, genocide and terrorism to name a few. This book had the same vibe I got from Mockingjay, with the violence unleashed in the pages…and this isn’t even war yet! It makes me wonder if the second book is as intense as I found the third Hunger Games book was, what more of Monsters of Men? I can’t imagine how dark that would be now.

This book blurs lines between the good and the bad guys, and truly, it’s hard to pick a side in the entire story. Should the end justify the means? Is terrorism the only way to achieve “peace”? Gray areas abound and the moral issues were tackled with the same detail as in Knife, but not too deep that it’s not so hard to understand. As if that’s not enough, Ness brings in another player into the field by the end of the novel, which I should have expected but took me by surprise.

My favorite character in this installment isn’t Todd or Viola, though, but Davy Prentiss. Davy, who only wanted to make his dad proud. Davy, who acts like a tough man but who’s really a boy. I loved how the relationship between Todd and Davy was developed, especially since I hardly saw it coming. It was easy to dismiss Davy as a villain especially after he shot Viola in the first book, but his evolution was a definite surprise. I am impressed at how Ness made him into a character that would earn the sympathy of the readers in the end.

Lately, I found myself balking whenever I see that a book I was about to start reading is more than 350 pages. With all the books in my TBR pile, I feel like I can’t invest that much time in a too thick book — you get what I mean? This book defied that though — it had 500+ pages but I hardly felt it. My friends, I think that is a good measure for a great book. :) While not as heart-wrenching as Knife (I admit that I’m still quite attached to that), The Ask and the Answer is a very good follow up in the trilogy. I am really looking forward to reading Monsters of Men now. Yes, I still need a breather before jumping into that, but I think I can promise that it won’t take another year before I crack my copy open. :)

Rating:

2011 Challenge Status:
Required Reading – September

Other reviews:
Persnickety Snark
The Book Smugglers
Book Harbinger

9 Thoughts on “The Ask and the Answer

  1. Yay! You finally read it. I’m glad it measured up. I love how Patrick Ness can make you sympathize with the bad guys every time. Oh, you will like Monsters of Men, but you’re right in guessing that you’re sort of dropped right in the middle of the action again, so you better be ready for that before you open it. Hopefully in a month or two? ;) Can’t wait to hear your thoughts.

    • Patrick Ness is so awesome, and I have a feeling Monsters of Men will prove that even more. And oh yes, I plan to read Monsters of Men later this year instead of waiting for another year. :)

  2. Hmmmm…. One year?! I couldn’t wait that long! Chaos Walking is my 2nd favorite YA trilogy! (My favorite would still have to be Phillip Pullman’s His Dark Materials.) I can’t imagine myself taking a year to get to the 2nd book, and you think you have a copy! But yes, I agree with you that Ness’s work tends to take a toll on you emotionally, but I love him for it! Hehehehe.

    My favorite in the series is the 3rd book, Monsters of Men. It’s so satisfying and heartbreaking. It was one of my best reads for 2010.

    • I know! I can’t believe it took me that long either. I actually have the entire trilogy on my shelf but I keep getting distracted with other books. Plus…Manchee broke my heart in the first book, so I took some time moving on. :P I do plan to read Monsters of Men before the year ends, though. :D

      I haven’t read Phillip Pullman’s trilogy yet (gasp!), but I promise to do so sometime. :) Oh, have you read Patrick Ness’ other book, A Monster Calls? That is awesome and emotional in a whole new level, and so far it’s my favorite book this year. :)

  3. I never really predicted where The Ask and the Answer would take me. By separating Todd and Viola and letting them experience different challenges, Patrick Ness gave his readers so much food for thought as well. I remember staying up all night just to finish this one — the action and the drama were really intense.

    • I think I would’ve stayed up all night reading this one too if I allowed myself to, but I wanted to savor it (that, and this was a buddy read, so I had to curb my speed-reading tendencies). :D I can’t wait to read Monsters of Men. :)

  4. I started reading this on the plane back from Florida and all of the feelings and emotions from reading TKoNLG came flooding back to me.

    I read two chapters, and had to put it down.

    I don’t know, I think it was too much, and I wasn’t prepared to read it in a spot where I didn’t have the ability to read it all in one sitting, I suppose. I didn’t feel like I should be reading it in a cramped spot on a plane. I wanted to be at home, in bed, on my couch, or some comfortable place where I could cry, yell, or throw the book.

    • I think I read most of this book at home, especially because I tend to gasp and suddenly close the book whenever something happens there. I think Patrick Ness books requires a break from reading it every now so the reader can regroup emotionally and such.

      Oh, and I think there will be book throwing moments in this one. ;)

  5. Pingback: Angelfall | One More Page

So, what do you think?

Post Navigation